Holloman Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Holloman bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Holloman AFB courtesy of Military Real Estate!

I need Suggestions....

who's talking here?

★Elizabeth★ 2
morgan 1
Short Momma 5
Christine 1
Sandra 3
Cathy 1
Shannon 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Short Momma --- 17 years ago -

Okay..So my daughter just turned 2 and she has been throwing major tantrums. I'm all for spanking her, but the thing is she doesn't feel anything nor does she mind it at all. She is the most stubbornish and rebellious child I have ever seen. Considering I was a very good child, I have no idea what to do with her. Spankins and room time are not working...any suggestions?? 

★Elizabeth★ --- 17 years ago -

i have a stubborn child too. time outs and spankings didnt work for her so we do wall sits. remember those from gym class where you sit against the wall in a pretend chair? after 5 seconds her behavior does a 180. 

Shannon --- 17 years ago -

my son is the same way. i ended up doing spanking and standing in the corner 

Cathy --- 17 years ago -

We got wonderful advice from Maggie Clark at Family Advocacy. There is a dvd you can rent about discipline that really helped us out. We use 1-2-3 Baby Magic. When they are screaming or throwing a tantrum, you slowly count to 3 (example: 1-Pick up the toy (after he has thrown it)-wait a few seconds; 2-Pick up the toy or you go to your room for 5 minutes-wait a few seconds; 3 and if he doesn't listen, we put him in his room for 5 minutes. My son can be stubborn but usually by 3, he does what he is asked. Oh, and if it is something like hitting his sister, it is an automatic 5 minutes in his room. Either way, Family Advocacy is a great source. 

Shannon --- 17 years ago -

spanking with a diaper or pull up on does not work for my son. i pull down his pull up and spank him. sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. my husband started spanking and putting him in the corner. that seems more effective. after two seconds he says "i'm done". lol 

★Elizabeth★ --- 17 years ago -

the counting thing didnt work for us. she just figured she could wait till right before we said 3 to do what we wanted. 

Short Momma --- 17 years ago -

Thanks for all the suggestions. I could try anything at this point. 

Christine --- 17 years ago -

Each of my kids were different. Abby seems to be the most headstrong. I am working at it. I have found that if I ignore her she seems to stop faster. If she hits, I slap her hand and tell her no. I try to spank only when it is life-threatening, like running toward the street. Sometimes if I can have her look me in the eye & talk calmly I can distract her and get her mind off of what she wants & can't have since that is where the most tantrums come from. 

morgan --- 17 years ago -

With Haylee we tried the hand-spanks but she started hitting our hands when we were doing something she didn't approved of. I have only spanked her once and I broke down in tears so that no longer happens! The counting to 3 didn't work for us either. She also would wait till 2 to stop what she was doing. Haylee has two different time-out spots. We put her in the recliner when it's something small like not listening. Shes still able to watch tv but has a time to sit and think about what she did wrong. If it's serious like hitting her brother shes sitting in a time-out chair by the door. Also once shes done we sit down with her and explain to her what she did wrong and why shes in trouble. If she hurts her brother/puppies we don't have a time limit of how long she has to stay in. Before she can come out she HAS to hug them and say sorry and love you. Sometimes she gets to upset and won't give hugs and stays in longer and sometimes she says it right away.. *Yes, I got that from Jon and Kate plus 8 lol* 

Sandra --- 17 years ago -

Short Momma, I had the same problem with one of my children. What worked for me was that I had to stop everything I was doing and fully consentrate on my child. I had to give him 100% of my attention. About 15 minutes into our playing or reading a story or sharing a snack, he would get bored with me and leave. I guess he had enough of me. Anyway, those 15 or so minutes worked. Each time no matter what I was doing I did this. Eventually he quit and learned to play and stop the winning and hanging over me. I didnt have to punish him.....or maybe I did. 

Short Momma --- 17 years ago -

Yeah, she throws herself on the floor smacking her head on anything. She slaps and I hit her back, and we continue doing this (never ending). My mom said it is just the terrible twos. I think my husband finally met his match though. I can't wait til she gets older!!! 

Sandra --- 17 years ago -

I'm no professional, but it could also be that your child cannot communicate so the only way to get your attention is to act out. Maybe one day you and your child can come to our play group and see how we teach our babies sign language. They are younger than two and when they want something they sign. It's wonderful. 

Short Momma --- 17 years ago -

I have been trying to give her more one on one attention, and I think that has helped. Sandra-sign language sounds cool...do they have to have an attention span? 

Sandra --- 17 years ago -

Because all babies are different and each one depending on their age and interest, have different levels of attention spans. Usually thier attention span seems longer when you are saying or doing something you don't want them to hear or learn. LOL What I do with mine is not sit and teach them, but usually as a one on one sign while I am doing something with them. Like hungry or eat when I am preparing food and getting ready to feed them, sign milk as I am pouring milk and giving it to them, hurt if they fall, poo poo when i am checking them and changing them, quiet time I sign "sleep" when it is time for nap, etc. When we sing songs we do some signing. Wheels on the bus is fun as I make up stuff. Our bus rides are long. lol. Everything I do with them is at their interest and time. We change often. Even the babies who don't participate or are doing other things eventually show you that they were listening. 

Short Momma --- 17 years ago -

Wow. That is cool. Tori is very smart but just gets bored easily. That sounds neat... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Holloman Underground